Where Creative Agencies Should and Shouldn’t Be Using AI
Saying that you use AI has started to feel like telling a friend that you texted your ex last night: just straight embarrassing.
Marketing agencies try to talk around it. Like they don’t participate in it, but they know someone who does. And the only thing more embarrassing than using it is lying that you don’t.
Whether we like it or not, AI has become the ex we keep crawling back to in moments of weakness. Need to write a thousand-word blog but can’t seem to find the time? Call Claude. That photo that Adobe Stock or Unsplash can’t seem to produce, Nano Banana is just a tab over. Gosh, AI is even producing websites at a speed faster than what it takes to swipe right on someone.
And, like most questionable relationships, this one has people picking sides.
On one end, you’ve got creatives swearing off AI like women who’ve decided they’re done dating men. On the other, you’ve got marketers running back to it for every minor inconvenience, one prompt away from asking ChatGPT what they’re wearing right now.
Both seem a little unhealthy.
On one side, they’ve been burned by repeated red flags: AI flyers and logos that everyone seems to be using, that they’ve sworn off the relationship entirely. Convinced it has nothing good to offer because they’ve only seen it at its worst (I mean, with icks like adding multiple fingers and whatever that paint stroke font is, it’s hard to ignore). The other has gotten a little too comfortable in the relationship and has sacrificed their personality and ability to think for themselves just to avoid doing any of the work.
Maybe (and hear us out), with a bit of ego-dropping, we as marketers can find balance in our relationship with AI. As with real relationships (aka the ones with actual homosapiens), by setting some healthy boundaries, we can let AI handle some of the chores, and we’ll help keep the spark alive. Because after all, a good relationship should make life better without losing yourself in the process.
Before you accuse us of unsolicited relationship advice, we should be honest about our own.
Yes, We’re Seeing AI. No, It’s Not That Serious.
Of course, it’s easy to preach about healthy boundaries when you’re not the one in the relationship. So, in the interest of transparency, let’s talk about our own.
We’ve found that when you set clear expectations with AI, it can be a decent partner. Specifically, when it comes to tasks that don’t really turn our creative energy on.
We’re talking about the unsexy stuff that happens behind closed doors. Cleaning up spreadsheets, troubleshooting code, extending image backgrounds, sorting through documents longer than an ex’s apology text. The type of tasks that need to get done but nobody expected to have to do when they said they wanted to work in marketing. And we’re happy in this relationship. Any partner who is willing to do the chores we’re thankful to have around.
Tell Me Everything. But Under 160 Characters.
When a recent client project came with a mountain of tedious work, we figured it was time to see if AI was willing to pull its weight. This client produces more podcasts than your typical alpha male can keep up with, which means there are a whole lot of episodes to keep organized. And with every episode comes a transcript that needs cleaning, formatting, and turning into a short, gripping summary for the website.
Apparently, all it took to find a partner who pulls their weight was abandoning the requirement that they be human. We used it to work through transcripts: cleaning up grammatical errors, removing timestamps and other unnecessary clutter, and helping turn conversations into concise episode descriptions. Producing summaries under 160 characters that actually reflect what was discussed, rather than some generic “join us as we explore” description that’s about as compelling as a “hey” message in your dm’s.
Of course, we still have standards. Episode titles needed to stay accurate, guests needed to be identified correctly, and their respective companies needed to be spelled correctly. We didn’t want to confuse Peloton with Palantir. AI handled the tedious cleanup, while we made sure the final product had enough personality to make it past the first date, and considering the number of transcripts, we never had any emotional breakdowns, and we didn’t even have to threaten to end things.
Good with its Hands. Still Requires Some Direction.
There’s also the administrative baggage. Meeting transcripts with enough back-and-forth to qualify as a custody dispute and research rabbit holes that leave you wondering whether his Aunt Linda’s Facebook posts are the reason nobody talks politics at Thanksgiving anymore. It’s good to let AI cut through the drama and pull out what actually matters. Personally, we’re still wondering what Aunt Linda thinks about government spending.
Our designers and developers are getting a little action too. Adobe Photoshop’s AI-powered tools can extend an image when a client needs a horizontal banner from a portrait-sized photo or make quick color and tonal adjustments without spending half an afternoon manually masking and retouching. It’s the digital equivalent of someone holding your hair back after a night of bad decisions; they didn’t create the mess, but they’re certainly helping you survive it.
Or when a website functionality decides to have a full-blown mental breakdown over one misplaced line of code, AI can be useful in figuring out what went wrong. We also use it for making HTML and CSS updates that would otherwise have us staring at our screens long enough to develop a personal vendetta against a semicolon. It’s still good to test everything before it goes live. We’ve seen enough to know that confidence and competence aren’t always on speaking terms.
The common denominator? Handing off the less glamorous work gives us more time to focus on what we’re actually good at and want to do.
We’re happy to delegate, but we’ve got enough opinions in this office without adding a chatbot to the mix.
Excuse Us, Who Said You Could Redecorate?
Now marketers seem to have lost the plot; we started choosing efficiency over creativity.
And yea, we get it. AI is available 24/7 and seemingly willing to do whatever you ask. You give it a prompt, and within seconds, it’s telling you exactly what you want to hear. For an industry built around unexpected client requests that were needed yesterday, it’s Hugh Jackman-level attractive.
But we’ve gotten so caught up in how quickly AI can produce something that we’ve stopped asking whether that something is any good.
We’ve gone Harrison Bergeron on our creativity. When we rely on the same technology to do our thinking, everything begins to look and act the same. Brands are willing to give up identity for a couple seconds spared. Content started sounding like GPT discovered em dashes and the phrase ‘in today’s fast-paced digital landscape’ and decided to make them everyone else’s problem.
We’ve gotten so comfortable letting AI make decisions for us that we’re slowly losing the personalities that made us interesting in the first place. We’ve become the friend who completely reinvents themselves to match whoever we’re dating.This is where we need boundaries.
We need to start valuing having something to put out there to the world, rather than being commited to getting something done faster just for speeds sake. We need to get back to the effort that comes in making good ideas. We need to bring back staring at email subject lines, desperately trying to manufacture the kind of chemistry that can’t be faked, no matter how hard you try. Sure it’s frustrating, but it is often what makes the final product worth a damn.
AI is more than happy to skip all of that and hand you something perfectly fine. It has absolutely no concern that your latest campaign looks like something your competitor posted last Tuesday.
Let’s realize we’ve started settling, and our clients deserve more than that.
We’re Not Breaking Up, But We Need Some Space
We’re not breaking up with AI, but we think a little distance would be healthy. It’s been good to us, and we’re not ready to go back to a life where we’re personally responsible for every menial task that crosses our desks (they don’t pay us the lower-middle-class bucks for nothing).
So we’re keeping it around. We appreciate what it brings to the relationship, but we’re also confident in our own decision-making skills. We’d like to think that’s a fairly reasonable expectation for functioning adults. It can help when we ask, but it doesn’t need to have an opinion on everything. We’ve already got enough men doing that.
After all, we’re happy to let AI be a freak in the sheets. But when it comes to the Creative Suite, we’d prefer to keep things human.
